moms4all

Beyond Books

These disputes also reached school apps, devices and online research tools. Groups sought new rules for software and student data privacy. Follow what they claimed, what they asked schools to change and which bills became law.

What else do these groups want schools to change?

Digital-resource safeguards

September 2020–May 2021 · Utah

On September 16, 2020, Nicholeen Peck spoke about EBSCO to the Judiciary Interim Committee. She was identified as president of the Worldwide Organization for Women and Utah Empowered Families Coalition. The committee voted 15–0, with one member absent, to open a bill file on access to pornography in schools. That allowed drafting; it did not change the law.

Show the dated details

HB38, School Technology Amendments, was signed on March 16, 2021 and took effect May 5. It required digital resources bought or licensed by UETN for public school students to prevent and filter obscene or pornographic material. Providers could lose future payments after notice of noncompliance. The law set a 90-day compliance check and required annual reports of provider failures.

Digital-policy proposals and response

2024–2026 · Utah

On January 22, 2024, Brooke Stephens supported HB261 at Senate Education, where the minutes identify her as Utah Parents United's education director. On January 31, 2025, she supported HB281 at House Education, speaking for Utah Moms for America.

Show the dated details

On February 19, 2025, she supported SB142, the App Store Accountability Act, as Moms for America Utah's civic engagement coordinator. On February 28, 2025, speaking for Utah Moms for America, she supported HB473 and discussed breaking vendor contracts. The Utah Library Association's Rebekah Cummings spoke against it.

On March 6, 2026, the Senate held HB197 and struck its enacting clause after House passage. The bill did not pass.

October 2022–August 2026; January 10, 2024 post · Utah; national advocacy service

Amplify USA launched on iOS on October 25, 2022 under Aaron Stephens. Early version notes add organization contact sharing, school-board lookup and precinct lookup. The Android version names S&S Apps as developer.

Show the dated details

On January 29, 2023, the StoryLabs storefront displayed a $45 Explicit Materials Brochure and an Amplify subscription page.

On January 10, 2024, Utah Parents United used Amplify USA to ask readers to email State Board members in support of repealing R277-328, the educational equity rule. S&S Apps, co-founded by Brooke and Aaron Stephens, makes Amplify. The post names Utah Parents United without identifying its author.

On August 28, 2026, Amplify described organization notifications and school-board lookup, and StoryLabs sold Amplify subscriptions and customized apps.

Devices, software and privacy claims

September 10, 2026; stated 2027 intentions · Utah; national comparison data

On September 10, 2026, Davis County Conservatives hosted a "Tech in Public Schools" talk by Liz and Allie of G-Rated School. They called for limits on school-issued devices, closer review of school software and student data privacy, and more software legislation in 2027.

Show the dated details

A presenter said a BYU and Internet Safety Labs review of 100 school apps found that 97 percent broke their data privacy agreements (DPAs). She also cited 52 percent collecting disallowed data and 36 percent sharing data with advertisers. The August 20, 2025 USBE/BYU/Internet Safety Labs report tested 100 selected apps. It found that 44 of the 85 apps with relevant DPAs (52 percent) collected data their agreements did not allow. The report does not give the claimed 97-percent result; its source is unknown.

In another excerpt, the presenter associated a flattening and then decline in reading scores with classroom computers and one device per student. She said the relationship is not known for sure, while calling the data conclusive, and described the chart as Utah data. The slide is labeled "NAEP Test Scores 8th Grade / READING" and ends at 256, with a four-point decrease from 2020 to 2023. The site notes that those values match the national NAEP long-term trend results for 13-year-olds, not a Utah state series.

A presenter said district accounts let students privately email others in the district. She raised concern about that ability but said she had no evidence of such a conversation.

The host thanked the presenters, offered help with lobbying lawmakers and said the group would email the talk to its members.

Open questions

Which proposals became policy? What vendor compliance actions followed? The sampling methods, risk definitions and evidence for any claim about cause also need review.